Skip to Content

9 Best Pacifiers For a Breastfed Baby

Every new parent has a deep understanding of exactly how challenging it can be to find the best pacifier for their little one. If you are on the hunt for one for your breastfed baby, things can get even trickier.

Not only do you want to ensure that they are safe and non-toxic pacifiers, but you also want to get one that will not interfere with your little angel’s feeding. 

So where do you even start? Well, look no further because we have got you covered. In this guide, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about pacifiers for breastfed babies.

You’ll learn exactly what to look for and we’ll also give you our recommendations for some of the best ones that you can buy right now. Keep reading to find the perfect pacifier for your little one!

This post may contain commissionable links. Thank you for supporting this resource.

Why do babies use pacifiers?

First things first, let’s talk about why babies use pacifiers. 

It’s a natural thing for babies to want to suck, and pacifiers provide a safe and easy way for them to do that.

Not only does it provide comfort and a sense of security, but it can also be a lifesaver during those moments when your newborn baby is fussy and you are trying to put her to sleep. 

Also, let’s be real, if you are exclusively breastfeeding, having only one way to soothe your little one can be exhausting. You need a break every once in a while. That’s where a pacifier will come in handy. 

However, you’ll want to find the right pacifier. Different pacifiers come in different sizes and shapes, and it is a good idea to find ones that are specifically designed for the breastfed baby in mind.

But wait, there’s more! 

The benefits of pacifiers do not stop there. Several studies have also shown that pacifier use can reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and promote the healthy development of the jaw, teeth, and speech! 

That said, it is important to point out that while they are great, pacifiers should not be used as a replacement for breastfeeding.

It is also best to wait until breastfeeding is well established before introducing them to the use of pacifiers so your baby doesn’t get confused by the artificial nipples from the real thing. 

When not used properly, a pacifier may become a possible choking hazard.

Best Pacifiers For a Breastfed Baby

What materials should you look for?

When it comes to pacifiers, the materials they are made from are just as important as the design. Here are the most important things to look for: 

  • Silicone: Silicone pacifiers are a popular choice among first-time moms and dads because they are so easy to clean. Silicone is also a durable, safe, and non-toxic material that can withstand sterilization and high temperatures. It’s also hypoallergenic, making it a great option for younger babies. It is usually labeled either medical-grade or food-grade silicone.
  • BPA-free: BPA is a chemical that can potentially be harmful to babies, so it’s best to avoid it in pacifiers. BPA is commonly found in plastics and has been shown to cause health issues like developmental delays in babies. Choosing a BPA-free pacifier will ensure that your baby is safe from these potential risks.
  • Latex-free: Some babies may have a latex allergy, so it’s best to choose a pacifier that is free of this material. Latex is a natural rubber that can be found in some pacifiers. It can cause allergic reactions in some babies, which may manifest as rashes or soreness of the skin. Choosing a latex-free pacifier will ensure that your baby is safe from any potential allergic reactions.

In addition to the materials, it’s also important to check the safety standards and certifications of the pacifier. Pacifiers that meet safety standards recommended by the AAP and FDA are recommended to ensure that your baby is using a safe and high-quality product.

What makes a good pacifier for a breastfed baby?

Here are some of the qualities to look for when choosing a pacifier for your breastfed baby:

Mimics the shape of a mother’s breast

The nipple shapes pacifiers are available in can vary. It’s best that the pacifier that mimics the shape of the breast, as it can make the transition between breastfeeding and using the pacifier a lot easier for your baby.

A pacifier that has a similar shape and texture to the mother’s nipple can also help to preserve the baby’s natural breastfeeding instincts and reduce the risk of nipple confusion.

Soft and flexible material 

Pacifiers that are made from a soft and flexible material will be more comfortable for your baby. This also makes them less likely to cause irritation.

It’s important to choose a pacifier with a soft nipple that is gentle on the baby’s gums and tongue, and that can adapt to the baby’s mouth shape.

Avoid pacifiers that are too hard or stiff as they can be uncomfortable for your little one. 

Has a large shield to prevent blocking the baby’s nose 

A large shield is essential if you want to prevent your little one’s nose from getting blocked and make it easier for her to breathe.

When a pacifier is too small or when it does not have an appropriately designed shield, it can obstruct your baby’s airways and make it hard for her to breathe properly.

The teat has a symmetrical shape

A symmetrically shaped pacifier is less likely to get turned around in your little one’s mouth and cause discomfort.

Additionally, pacifiers that are symmetrical are more comfortable for babies to hold and less likely to cause oral irritation.

Has a textured grip for your baby to hold

As your little one grows older, she will want to be more independent when it comes to putting her favorite pacifier in her mouth on her own.

Having a textured surface or a convenient grip on the pacifier will allow your baby to have something to hold onto as she pacifies herself.

It will also make the pacifier less likely to drop out or get lost during use. You can also use a pacifier clip to help keep track of the pacifier.

9 Best Pacifiers To Try For a Breastfed Baby

Here is a look at our top recommendations for the best pacifiers for a breastfed baby.

Note that while all of these are great options for your little one, you should use pacifiers responsibly.

Pacifiers are designed to be used to comfort and soothe your baby, not as a replacement for breastfeeding.

Without further ado, let’s dive right in, shall we? 


Price: $16.95
Material: Silicone

Top Pick
07/18/2024 05:26 am GMT

The WubbaNub pacifier stands out because it features an animal toy attached to the pacifier, making it easy for babies to hold onto.

It comes with a plush toy that provides additional comfort to your little one, making it a great option for babies who are transitioning from the breast to the bottle

This medical-grade silicone pacifier is Latex free, BPA, PVC, and phthalate free. The plush animal is also machine washable. 


Price: $9.99
Material: Silicone

07/18/2024 05:27 am GMT

The Nanobebe pacifier is designed to mimic the shape of a mother’s breast, making it a good choice for breastfeeding babies. It’s made from medical-grade silicone and is BPA-free and phthalate-free. 

You’ll also love the seamless design that gives it the most comfortable fit in your baby’s mouth is approved by the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines.

As well as the unique shape of the pacifier that promotes healthy jaw and teeth development. The pacifier also has a patented design that allows for easy cleaning and sterilization. 

MAM Original Start 

Price: $7.99
Material: Silicone

Mam Original Start pacifiers are designed with a symmetrical shape and a small textured surface for babies to grip.

There is no right side up to this pacifier, which means the mam pacifier will always be perfectly adjusted and well-positioned under your baby’s nose for easy breathing. 

It’s made from medical-grade silicone and is BPA-free.

The shield is also designed with ventilation holes to allow air to circulate and prevent skin irritation. It is also available in different colors, designs, and sizes for newborns, infants, and older babies. 

Tommy Tippee Ultra Light 

Price: $15.99
Material: Silicone

The Tommy Tippee Ultra Light pacifier is designed to be lightweight, making it easy for babies to hold onto. It will also stay in your baby’s mouth for longer. 

It’s made from medical-grade silicone and is BPA-free. The orthodontic shape is also designed to promote the healthy development of teeth and gums, approved by pediatric dentists.

It comes with a hygienic travel cap that keeps the pacifier clean and safe. Plus, it is dishwasher-safe!

NUK Comfort 

Price: $9.49
Material: Silicone

Coming in a pack of 5, NUK Comfy pacifiers are designed to mimic the shape of a mother’s breast. This makes them a great choice for breastfeeding babies. 

This pacifier comes with a large shield to prevent blocking the baby’s nose. It is made from medical-grade silicone and BPA-free materials. The tip is also extra soft for a comfortable fit. 

Phillips Notched Newborn 

Price: $9.85
Material: Silicone

The Phillips Notched Newborn pacifier is designed specifically for newborns with a notched shape that fits comfortably in the baby’s mouth.

It’s made from medical-grade silicone and BPA-free materials and is completely dishwasher-safe. 

The notched shape is also designed to prevent the pacifier from obstructing your baby’s nose.

It features a unique curved design that fits securely in baby’s mouth and promotes healthy oral development.

Tommy Tippee Breast-Like 

Price: $12.88
Material: Silicone

The Tommy Tippee Breast Like pacifier stands out because of its unique award-winning design.

It mimics the shape of a mother’s breast, making it a good choice for breastfeeding babies and infants. It’s made from medical grade silicone and BPA-free materials. 

It is designed to help with your baby’s transition. This makes it a wonderfully reassuring alternative to standard pacifiers because it feels like human skin, reducing the risk of nipple confusion.

It also has a unique air-ventilated shield that makes it more breathable for your baby’s delicate skin. Finally, it has the symmetrical shape of orthodontic pacifiers which promotes healthy oral development. 

Dr. Brown’s Happy Paci 

Price: $5.99
Material: Silicone

07/18/2024 05:37 am GMT

Dr. Brown’s Happy Paci has a soft and flexible material that mimic the shape of a mother’s breast and is designed to promote healthy development of the jaw, teeth, and speech.

It is BPA-free, has a large shield and is designed to prevent blocking the baby’s nose. 

Coming in a one-piece design, it has a comfortable contoured butterfly-shaped shield that will always give your little one’s face lots of room as she uses it. It also has a unique vented design that allows air to circulate and prevent skin irritation. 

Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Pacifiers 

Price: $6.79
Material: Rubber

07/18/2024 05:44 am GMT

The Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber pacifier stands out because it is made using natural rubber. It comes in a pack of 2 that closely mimic the feeling of breastfeeding. It is 100% BPA-free and latex-free. 

You’ll love the symmetrical shape as well as the textured surface that makes it easy for your little one to grip it.

Additionally, the natural rubber material is soft and flexible and also biodegradable. It is also very easy to clean and sterilize. 

Final Thoughts

With so many options available in the market today, finding the perfect pacifier for your breastfed baby can be a rather daunting task. However, when you have the right information and you know where to start, it won’t be. 

As you can see, we’ve done the research and compiled this list of some of the best and safest pacifiers that you can buy for your little one today. From pacifiers with plush animals attached to those designed specifically for newborns, we’ve got you covered.

With this list, you should be able to get the perfect soothing solution for your baby. Happy pacifying!

About the Author

Nicole Booz is the founder of GenTwenty and GenThirty. She is an entrepreneur, author of The Kidult Handbook, and most importantly, Mama to two beautiful little boys. She loves reading, organizing her home, and living a simple, less toxic lifestyle. You've seen her in The New York Times, TIME, Insider, Inside Edition, New York Post, NextAdvisor, Forbes, Yahoo, HuffPost, and U.S. News & World Report.